2013 Supreme Court judgment Dobbs vs. Jackson Health Dramatically and rapidly changing the landscape of abortion access in the United States, the court upheld a Mississippi law on June 24, 6-3, which would prohibit abortion after 15 weeks of gestation, but also reverse the nearly half-century precedent. Rowe vs. Wade Which has ensured the constitutional right to abortion. With Dobbs Decision, states have the power to set their own restrictions, so where people live they will determine the level of access to abortion.
The majority opinion, written by Justice Samuel Alito, states that “the Constitution does not grant the right to abortion; Rowe And Casey [Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 1992] is overruled; And the power to control abortion is returned to the people and their elected representatives. ”
Almost as soon as the decision was announced, protests and celebrations began outside the court and across the country – highlighting the patchwork of laws and restrictions that will now take effect. State officials in conservative states have said they will take swift action to limit abortions, while in other states, some officials have promised to have the right of access.
Here are five key factors that will affect access to abortion.
1. Where is abortion still legal?
The Supreme Court ruling means that access to abortion will soon become very unequal.
Sixteen states and the District of Columbia have laws that protect the right to abortion. In the other two states, courts have ruled that the state constitution establishes that right. These states are concentrated on the east and west coasts.
At the other end of the spectrum, 13 states have “trigger” laws that will quickly ban almost all abortions and at least a dozen and a half moved to implement them Friday, including Arkansas, Kentucky, Missouri and South Dakota. Four more pre-Rowe Prohibition which will be effective again. The other three states have laws on books that would prohibit abortion after about six weeks of gestation.
Other states are also likely to develop access to abortion. Kansas and Montana, states that have abortion rights enshrined in their constitutions, could see a rollback to those protections through various efforts by state legislators or the ballot system. In at least eight states, the right to abortion is not explicitly protected or prohibited by state law.
And in Michigan, a state law of 1931 prohibited almost all abortions, but its application was temporarily suspended by a May court decision. Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat, has said she will not enforce the law, but local prosecutors have questions about whether it will.
As was the case before the 1973 Supreme Court Rowe The decision is that people are also subject to a variety of restrictions on abortion care, even in states where the procedure is still legal. These include the gestational limit which outlines the maximum point of pregnancy that anyone can get an abortion, the need for patients to get counseling in advance, the waiting period and the rules of parental notice for minors.
2. What can the Biden administration do?
President Joe Biden says his administration is looking at executive measures to counteract the impact of the ruling. In comments after the decision, Biden said it was a “sad day” and without Rowe, “the health and lives of women in this nation are now at risk.”
But in short, without a new law from Congress, it has limited options.
Proponents of her case have been working to make the actual transcript of this statement available online. Proponents of her case have been working to make the actual transcript of this statement available online. Says that the procedure prohibits and strengthens digital privacy to protect patients.
According to the Guttmacher Institute, a research organization that supports abortion rights, drug abortions have become an increasingly large part of total abortions in the United States, with more than half of all abortion pills in 2020, with first-year drugs providing the majority.
Under the Biden administration, the Food and Drug Administration has already lifted a major restriction. Now, patients can receive the first drug used in the series, Mifepristone, by mail. Mary Ziegler, a professor at the University of California at Davis School of Law and a legal historian of abortion, says that even if conservative states reduce access to drug abortion, the Biden administration could argue that the FDA’s rules and guidelines on mifepristone are advanced. Any state law criminalizes that procedure. Attorney General Merrick Garland took the position in a statement that he stated shortly after the decision was announced: “The FDA has approved the use of the drug mifepristone. States cannot ban Mifepristone on the basis of disagreement with the FDA’s expert opinion on its safety and effectiveness. “Biden reinforced that message in his remarks.
In comments before the judges announced their decision, Zeigler said the argument for the position was “the biggest thing they can do.” Yet, the FDA approach is uncertain, both legally and because the future Republican administration could easily reverse any action taken by Biden officials. “If it works, it won’t last, and it may not work,” he added. The Biden administration can also expand the number of pharmacies that can supply drugs.
3. Can people in states where abortion is illegal be able to have a medical abortion?
As a result for now Dobbs The decision says that banning abortion may also result in restrictions or bans on abortion pills. But some lawyers note that people in that state may still be able to get abortion pills and have a “self-administered” abortion at home, which carries some additional risks if the woman has complications (although complications are very rare). And abortion pills will still be accessible in states where abortion is allowed.
Prior to the reversal, many states had already banned the use of abortion pills, including banning the delivery of pills by post and not allowing patients to be prescribed medication through telemedicine appointments. But people have found a solution – a practice that is likely to continue. These activities – such as traveling to a neighboring state to secure a drug or sending it to a friend’s home or elsewhere in a post office box – may again carry the risk of criminal charges, depending on the specifics of state law.
There are also concerns among abortion rights activists that states that illegal abortions could go further and criminalize travel to other states for abortions, although this is an untested legal boundary and will probably be tied to the courts.
In his remarks, Biden took a tough stance on the question, saying the court’s decision does not preclude a woman living in a state that prohibits abortion from traveling to a state. Women “should be free to travel safely to other states to receive the care they need,” he said, adding that his administration would “protect the rights of that foundation.” He further mentioned that doctors in the states that allow abortions can provide abortions to women from other jurisdictions.
4. How will this affect doctors’ ability to provide care?
In many states that prohibit abortion, obstetricians, gynecologists, emergency room doctors, and any kind of physician caring for pregnant women will likely be targeted by law and may face criminal charges if they provide abortion services.
It will have a devastating effect on reproductive health care, Dr. Nicki Jite, an OB-GYN in Knoxville, Tenn., Recently told KHN. Tennessee’s Trigger Act states that abortion is permitted only to prevent a death or “to prevent a significant risk of significant and irreversible obstruction of a pregnant woman’s major physical activity.”
“But it’s not clear exactly how much risk there needs to be,” Zite said. “Different physicians practicing in different institutions will have different interpretations of that law.”
There are also gray areas that are not covered by the law. In some very early pregnancies, the fertilized egg remains outside the uterus – usually in the fallopian tube – a potentially life-threatening condition called an ectopic pregnancy. If such a pregnancy progresses, the woman may bleed.
Patients who have a miscarriage also sometimes have to take abortion drugs or undergo dilation and curette surgery – known as D&C – to remove the tissue inside the uterus.
“The challenge is that abortion treatment and abortion treatment are exactly the same,” Dr. Sarah Pragar recently told KHN. Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the University of Washington in Seattle, Prague, and a specialist in early pregnancy loss.
Doctors may hesitate to do D&C for abortion treatment for fear that anyone will accuse them of performing a secret abortion.
“Physicians should not be afraid to be guilty of caring for patients,” Zite said. “I think there are going to be unintended consequences. I think people will lose their lives. I also think there will be people in horrible situations, like they desperately want to get pregnant but there is a complication of pregnancy, they will not be able to decide how that pregnancy will end and it will be a different kind of catastrophe. ”
5. Can this verdict affect more than just abortion?
Absolutely, according to reproductive health experts. Depending on what is defined as an “abortion,” states may criminalize – intentionally or accidentally – in vitro fertilization and certain types of birth control, and limit the training and availability of doctors and other healthcare providers.
What is determined to be an abortion at risk. Clinically, abortion is an early termination of pregnancy, a natural intervention – spontaneous abortion, or abortion – or human intervention through medication or surgery. But when does pregnancy begin? Doctors say that pregnancy begins when a fertilized egg is implanted in a woman’s uterus. But many anti-abortion activists say it starts when a sperm and egg combine to form a zygote, which can occur several days earlier. That earlier period means that anything that interferes with the implantation of that fertilized egg, such as an IUD (pregnancy device), a common form of birth control, can be defined as an abortion. Similarly, in vitro fertilization, which involves removing a woman’s eggs, fertilizing them, and then implanting them back into the woman, can also be considered abortion until each fertilized egg is implanted.
An opinion of Justice Clarence Thomas that agrees with the decision to quash Rowe Raise other questions. He suggested that the court could use the same argument Dobbs In case of revocation of other key judgments including birth control and establishment of same-sex marriage It was not clear if the other judges agreed, and Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the keynote address, said he did not believe the abortion decision affected other issues.
The American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians and Gynecologists applauded the decision, calling it “important.” Others, however, are concerned that the ruling has stricter abortion laws or could have a negative impact on women’s access to care in enacted areas. In particular, doctors and other health professionals do not want to train or practice in areas where they may be judged for providing medical care.
And it’s not just theoretical. In Texas, where abortion after six weeks of gestation has been effectively banned since September, according to a report in The New England Journal of Medicine, the law “affects the mental health of physicians; Some physicians have reported feeling ‘worse doctors’ and some are leaving the state. As a result, physicians are concerned that pregnant Texans are being left without a care option and without a doctor capable of providing it. ”
Contact us Submit a story tip